Senate Keeps Trump's Iran Powers
The Senate rejected a resolution that would have directed President Donald Trump to remove US forces from hostilities with Iran, leaving his war powers as they were. Three Republicans voted for the measure and one Democrat voted against it, and it failed 48 to 51.

Archive photo: The Senate side of the US Capitol's east front, June 2014.Illustration by Agentic Newsgathering, based on a photo by David (Flickr) (CC BY 2.0). The painting carries the same CC BY 2.0 license.
The Senate rejected a resolution that would have directed President Donald Trump to remove US armed forces from hostilities with Iran. The vote was 48 in favor and 51 against. Three Republicans, Senators Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky, voted for it, and one Democrat, Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, voted against. Republican Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina, who had backed earlier efforts, also voted no. The House of Representatives approved the same measure in September. It was the first time either chamber had voted on the war since the November 3 midterm elections, in which Republicans lost control of both the House and the Senate. Its effect would have been largely symbolic. A 1973 law, the War Powers Resolution, says a president must withdraw forces from hostilities when Congress so directs by this kind of resolution, but administrations of both parties have argued that the procedure is unconstitutional. Trump, asked separately about new strikes on Iran, said, "We'll see what happens after January 1." The new Congress, with Democrats in control of both chambers, will take office on January 3.
Text of the measure
The measure, House Concurrent Resolution 93, would have directed the president "to remove United States Armed Forces from hostilities with Iran." A concurrent resolution passes both the House and the Senate but does not go to the president for a signature, which is why its legal force is disputed. Under the War Powers Resolution, the president must withdraw forces from hostilities "if the Congress so directs by concurrent resolution." Administrations of both parties have argued that this procedure is unconstitutional, and the White House argued against the validity of a similar measure adopted over the summer.
The House approved the resolution in September, before it reached the Senate.
The vote leaves the president's war powers unchanged. The administration said last week that it believes its blockade and economic sanctions against Iran are working, Reuters reported.
Vote by vote
Collins, Murkowski and Paul, all Republicans who had supported earlier resolutions, joined Democrats in voting yes. Fetterman was the only Democrat to vote no. Senator Chris Murphy, a Connecticut Democrat, did not vote; The Washington Post reported that he is recovering from a stroke.
Tillis, who had sided with Democrats on previous war powers votes, voted against this one. "This one doesn't go to the president, so it's just a statement from Congress. I've made that statement," he told reporters. Tillis told CBS News he was using the funding process instead "to try and figure out how to replenish supplies, but hold Hegseth accountable," referring to Secretary of War Pete Hegseth. "I think I've been pretty clear that I think he's a failure," Tillis said.
Senator Tim Kaine, a Virginia Democrat who has led the party's efforts to restrict the president on Iran, urged Republicans to back the measure in a floor speech before the vote. He said the war's unpopularity "was made absolutely manifestly clear in the election results from Nov. 3." "And so it is my hope, that in the aftermath of a clear message from the American public that they want us to stop this illegal, catastrophic war, the Senate will demonstrate that we're listening," Kaine said, according to CBS News. Democratic Senators Peter Welch of Vermont and Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin also spoke on Iran before the vote, and Republican Senator Tim Sheehy of Montana spoke against the resolution.
Earlier attempts
Democrats have forced more than a dozen war powers votes since the war began in late February, when the United States and Israel launched strikes on Iran, and most have fallen short. One resolution passed both chambers in June: the House approved it 215-208 on June 3, and the Senate 50-48 on June 23 with the votes of four Republicans. Trump took aim at the Republicans who had supported it at a lunch with Senate Republicans the next day, where he clashed with one of them, Senator Bill Cassidy of Louisiana. Another House-passed resolution narrowly failed in the Senate before the midterms, CBS News reported.
The Constitution gives Congress the power to declare war and makes the president commander in chief. The War Powers Resolution, passed after the Vietnam War, was meant to require congressional approval for sustained military action after 60 or 90 days.
Trump on what comes next
Speaking to Reuters on Air Force One as he flew back from China, Trump was asked about the possibility of new strikes on Iran. "Well, I'll talk to you about it after the beginning of the year," he said. "We've got time." He told Fox News, "We'll see what happens after January 1," and told a reporter for Axios and Israel's News 12, "I'm not rushing to make any decisions on Iran," according to Reuters.
In the weeks before the November 3 elections, Trump repeatedly suggested that Iran would be more willing to make a deal once the votes were counted. Speaking to Reuters about the election losses, Trump said, "And the big thing is if you had to do it again, would you do it? And the answer is yes. Because you can't let Iran have a nuclear weapon." He has acknowledged that the war played a role in his party's election losses but has said he would not have changed course, Reuters reported.
Republicans will hold their Senate majority until January 3, when the new Congress, with Democrats in control of both chambers, takes office.