07 · Courts and immigration · New York

Court Orders NYC to Name Shelter Residents for ICE

A federal judge ordered the city to give immigration agents the names and birth dates of men at its last emergency migrant shelter who have been charged with serious crimes.

The Daniel Patrick Moynihan U.S. Courthouse in Lower Manhattan, May 2026.

The Daniel Patrick Moynihan U.S. Courthouse in Lower Manhattan, May 2026.Illustration by The Good Times, based on a photo by Flickr user 83136374@N05 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

In one minute

A federal judge in Manhattan ordered New York City to comply with a subpoena from Immigration and Customs Enforcement for the names, birth dates and identifying records of certain men living at the city's last emergency migrant shelter, a converted warehouse on Bruckner Boulevard in the South Bronx. Judge Lewis Kaplan limited the order to residents charged with any of eight crimes: murder, manslaughter, rape, robbery, assault, grand larceny, burglary or assault of a law enforcement officer. A charge is an accusation, not a conviction. A court-appointed special master will review the shelter's records and decide which names qualify. ICE had asked for every resident. "The City has not shown that producing this list would be unduly burdensome," Kaplan wrote. The city, which bars its agencies from cooperating with ICE, had called an earlier request a "fishing expedition." Mayor Zohran Mamdani says the city is evaluating all its legal options. In a sworn statement, an ICE official said the agency knows of 20 residents who entered the country illegally and 12 who had been charged with a "serious" offense.

New York City must give Immigration and Customs Enforcement the names and birth dates of certain men living at its last emergency migrant shelter, U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan ruled.

The order covers residents of the city-run shelter at 825 East 141st Street and Bruckner Boulevard, in the Mott Haven section of the South Bronx, who have "serious criminal histories," defined as being charged with any of eight crimes: murder, manslaughter, rape, robbery, assault, grand larceny, burglary or assault of a law enforcement officer. A charge is an accusation, not a conviction. The city must also hand over records that would help ICE identify those residents. A special master appointed by the court will review the shelter's records and decide which names qualify. According to the Bronx Times, Kaplan gave the city two weeks to comply, under a plan in which the city and ICE may submit a proposal to the special master, who will oversee the transfer of the data.

What ICE asked for and what the judge allowed

ICE originally sought the names and records of every male resident. Kaplan's ruling narrowed the request to residents charged with the eight crimes and gave the special master the job of deciding who qualifies. ICE says it needs the information for an investigation into residents who may be subject to deportation. In a sworn affidavit, an ICE official said the agency knows of 20 immigrant residents who entered the country illegally and 12 who had been charged with a serious offense.

The city argued that ICE was using its subpoena power to "circumvent and undermine the City's sanctuary city laws" and called an earlier request a "fishing expedition lacking any legitimate investigative purpose." Kaplan found nothing in the record suggesting ICE wanted the names for any reason other than enforcing immigration law. "The City has not shown that producing this list would be unduly burdensome," he wrote. "Under the applicable case law, the Court therefore has no choice but to compel the subpoena's enforcement." ICE has filed four subpoenas for information on city shelter residents since August 2025.

The city's response

Mayor Zohran Mamdani said the city is "reviewing that decision and evaluating all our legal options," and his spokesperson, Ivonne Rodriguez, said City Hall is "evaluating next steps." State Attorney General Letitia James said she is also evaluating the matter. The New York Immigration Coalition, which represents more than 200 immigrant and refugee groups, has urged the city to appeal. The Department of Homeland Security declined to comment, citing the litigation.

The shelter

The shelter opened in February 2025 in a converted warehouse built to hold up to 2,200 men. It had 1,670 residents in February and just over 1,400 at the end of June, according to City Council data. At the height of the migrant influx the city ran more than 260 shelters for more than 240,000 migrants and asylum seekers; this is the last emergency site, and Mamdani has said he plans to close it by the end of the year.

Sources

More from today

02 · Politics · Washington

House Shelves Hegseth Impeachment

The House voted 211-204 on a motion to refer Rep. Thomas Massie's impeachment resolution against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee; Massie was the only Republican to vote no.

03 · Housing · New York

East Harlem Buildings Go to Auction

Lenders auctioned the first 15 of 38 rundown rent-stabilized buildings in East Harlem after rejecting a city-backed buyer; only one drew a bid.

04 · Technology · United States

AI Checks Signal's Math

Google DeepMind used AI agents to formally prove that core parts of the Signal encryption code do what they promise, which DeepMind calls a first for a protocol this widely used.

05 · Trade · Beijing

China's Surplus Passes $1 Trillion

China sold $1.04 trillion more goods than it bought in the first 10 months of the year, driven by global demand for AI hardware.

08 · Opinion

Waiting on the Free Bus

The war over free buses was lost in Albany months ago. City Hall is still fighting it in press statements, and the mayor owes New Yorkers a plain answer.