US Faults Ukraine's Deep Strikes
The United States told Ukraine's military backers that Kyiv's long-range strikes deep inside Russia have not shortened the war and that their support should go to the front line instead. Germany's defense minister, Boris Pistorius, called the warning "quite a stupid thing."

Archive photo: NATO headquarters in Brussels, September 2018.Illustration by Agentic Newsgathering, based on a photograph by Swadim (CC BY-SA 4.0).
The United States told Ukraine's military backers that Kyiv's long-range strikes deep inside Russia have not worked and that their support should go to the front line instead. Elbridge Colby, the under secretary of war for policy, made the case at a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group at NATO headquarters in Brussels, speaking on behalf of Secretary of War Pete Hegseth. "Our assessment is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia's advances on the front line," Colby said, according to the official transcript of his remarks. Strikes on civilian targets, he said, had "probably hardened the Russian public's resolve." He added that strikes on Russia's war-making machinery can still help, and that the burden of arming Ukraine will rest mainly on Europe. Germany's defense minister, Boris Pistorius, called the warning "quite a stupid thing." Britain's defense secretary, Wes Streeting, said the strikes had "helped to degrade Putin's war machine." Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, speaking by video link, asked for Patriot and IRIS-T interceptors from existing stocks and 40 more F-16 fighter jets.
What Colby told the allies
Elbridge Colby spoke at the contact group, a regular meeting of countries that supply Ukraine with weapons, convened at NATO headquarters by Germany's defense minister, Boris Pistorius, and Britain's defense secretary, Wes Streeting, with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte taking part.
He said Ukrainian forces had "rightly focused on defending the front lines" with a mid-range drone campaign against Russian supply lines, which he called "very effective." Mid-range strikes are attacks close enough to the fighting to hit the roads, depots and units that feed a battlefield advance, rather than targets far inside Russia.
"While the public conversation focuses on the spectacle of deep strikes designed to incur pain on the Russian population, our assessment is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia's advances on the front line," Colby said. Deep strikes are long-range attacks on targets well behind the front, including energy facilities, military sites and, in some cases, commercial infrastructure.
Strikes that target civilian infrastructure, he said, naming the Russian online retailer Wildberries, "have actually probably hardened the Russian public's resolve and the Kremlin's own willingness to escalate." He added that "the balance of advantage in deep strikes may well favor Moscow."
The Associated Press, in a dispatch published by the Los Angeles Times, reported that Ukraine has repeatedly struck Wildberries, Russia's largest online retailer, and that Kyiv says the company sells equipment used by the Russian military, which the company denies. The AP also noted that President Donald Trump has demanded that Ukraine halt strikes on Russian oil refineries and on infrastructure used to produce and distribute diesel, saying the attacks are causing a global shortage. Euronews likewise reported that Trump has previously blamed those attacks for higher diesel prices.
Colby said this did not mean Ukraine "should be forced to fight with its hands tied behind its back," and that strikes on "Russia's warmaking machinery can also help contribute to slowing Russia's advance on the front lines." He said the focus of allied support should be "enabling and advancing Ukraine's ability to hold the line of battle and, where possible, make gains."
In October, Colby said, Ukraine gained more territory than Russia for the second month in a row, and Russian forces suffered their highest monthly casualties of the war. Those figures are his; the remarks do not cite an independent tally.
Who pays for the weapons
Colby told the allies to prepare for a long war. "As winter sets in, however, it appears that Russia will continue to generate more manpower and mobilize its war economy for the long-haul," he said. The United States, he said, is putting its own readiness in the Western Hemisphere and the Indo-Pacific first.
Ukraine will need "robust funding" for PURL, an initiative Colby described as essential to "sustaining the flow of critical munitions" to Ukrainian troops, and "this responsibility, however, will primarily rest on Europe's shoulders." He said Europe had already "stepped up to do this over the last eighteen months." He also said the United States would keep helping allies obtain high-end weapons for Ukraine through a program he called JUMPSTART, and he praised a European Union decision to fund the first partner-paid purchase of Patriot interceptors, the missiles used by a US-made air-defense system of that name.
He urged Europe to build weapons for "military efficacy and battlefield utility, rather than ancillary domestic or industrial policy objectives," and said partners should not underestimate the importance of the president's budget request for US munitions and drone production.
The European response
Pistorius rejected the American warning in public after the meeting. Asked whether he shared Colby's view, the German defense minister said, according to Anadolu Agency and Interfax-Ukraine, that "criticizing strikes like that in Russia to destroy strategic military and military-used targets is quite a stupid thing, I think." He said the allies should instead talk about "the terroristic strikes every night and every day on civil energy, water, and heater infrastructure in Ukraine," which he called "kind of terrorism," and about "legal and legitimate strikes in Russia against non-civilian targets."
Streeting told reporters, according to Politico Europe, that it was "not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war." He said there was "no doubt" in his mind that the long-range strikes had "helped to degrade Putin's war machine, buying time and saving lives," Euronews reported.
What Ukraine asked for
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky told the meeting, by video link, "Ukraine needs Patriot and IRIS-T interceptors from the stocks you already have right now. And I ask the United States, please, do not delay these deliveries." IRIS-T is a German-made air-defense system. He said Ukraine also needed another 40 F-16 fighter jets for its air defenses, Euronews reported.
The Associated Press reported that Zelensky has separately warned that limits on Starshield, a satellite communications system operated by SpaceX, could weaken defenses around Ukraine's energy infrastructure as winter approaches. Asked about those restrictions, Colby declined to discuss them, the AP said, and then told reporters the United States was "very focused on supporting Ukraine's ability to defend itself and these kind of mid-range strikes."
- U.S. Department of War (Colby remarks, as delivered)
- Euronews (November 17)
- Los Angeles Times (Associated Press, November 17)
- Anadolu Agency (November 17)