06 · Diplomacy · Europe

Europe Rejects a Deal Without It

Kaja Kallas and Radosław Sikorski say Europe must participate in any security arrangement after Donald Trump points to a potential agreement extending beyond Ukraine.

The Berlaymont, the European Commission's headquarters in Brussels, April 2023.

The Berlaymont, the European Commission's headquarters in Brussels, April 2023.Illustration by The Good Times, based on a photo by Leo Van Vreckem / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

In one minute

European officials have rejected the prospect of a U.S.–Russia agreement deciding the continent’s security without European participation. EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said the Union would not implement an arrangement it had no part in negotiating, while Polish Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski called a deal about Europe made over its head impossible. Their remarks in Warsaw followed President Donald Trump’s prediction of a “very big” agreement with Moscow that might involve all of Europe, not only Ukraine. No detailed or signed agreement was announced. Trump’s envoy Jared Kushner has called for a broader European security framework and said European partners would be consulted. Kallas said Europe already had a security architecture and that Russian President Vladimir Putin had no veto over it. Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha likewise opposed decisions about Ukraine without Ukraine. The dispute concerns the scope and participation in prospective negotiations, rather than Europe rejecting a published final pact.

European officials have rejected any attempt by Washington and Moscow to decide the continent’s security arrangements without European participation, after President Donald Trump suggested a potential agreement with Russia could extend beyond Ukraine.

EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas and Polish Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski set out that position at a press conference in Warsaw on November 6. Kallas said the European Union would not implement an agreement negotiated without it.

“Any agreement that we are not party of, we are not going to implement either,” she said, according to Kyiv Post. Sanctions, frozen Russian assets, reconstruction and Ukraine’s entry into the EU require decisions by European institutions, she noted.

Sikorski likewise rejected the idea that the United States and Russia could settle Europe’s future alone. “An arrangement about the future of Ukraine and of Europe above our heads would not just be unwise. It is actually impossible,” he said.

Their comments followed Trump’s remarks on November 5 that an agreement with Moscow could be “very big” and “might involve all of Europe.” He did not present detailed terms. There was no announcement of a signed U.S.–Russia pact or of European governments accepting a new security arrangement.

Trump’s envoy and son-in-law, Jared Kushner, has said Washington is working on a broader European security framework. American representatives held discussions in Brussels with officials from NATO, the EU and European governments about guarantees for Ukraine and wider security arrangements, Euronews reported.

Kushner said the United States intended to consult European partners around the forthcoming Abu Dhabi negotiations and, if progress was achieved, move toward a broader multilateral format with their participation. His account therefore described further negotiations, not an agreement already in force.

Kyiv Post reported that Kallas rejected rewriting existing European arrangements to accommodate Moscow. She said Putin had no veto over European security. “We already have a European security architecture in place,” she said. “The problem remains that Russia keeps breaking the treaties that underpin it.”

She also opposed legal recognition of Russia’s claims to occupied Ukrainian territory and restrictions on Ukraine’s armed forces. An agreement ending the war must prevent Russia from using a pause to rearm and attack again, she said.

Ukraine’s Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha, who joined the Warsaw press conference, said Russia could not be a guarantor of security for the continent. “Nothing about Ukraine without Ukraine. Nothing about Europe without Europe,” he said.

The comments set out the limits European and Ukrainian officials want to apply to the U.S.-led diplomatic process. Talks with Russia and Ukraine are scheduled in Abu Dhabi for November 10 and 11. The public dispute is over who participates and what those negotiations may cover, not the rejection of a published final treaty.

Sources

More from today

02 · Diplomacy · Abu Dhabi

Russia Adds to Talks Team

The Kremlin says Sergei Ryabkov and a senior General Staff officer will join the Russian delegation for U.S.-mediated negotiations with Ukraine in Abu Dhabi.

03 · Shipping · Asia / Europe

Evergreen Plans a Suez Return

The Taiwanese carrier has scheduled a limited set of sailings through the canal and Red Sea, joining other lines shifting away from the longer Cape route.

04 · Politics · Israel

Eisenkot Gets First Chance

Isaac Herzog chooses Gadi Eisenkot to try to form Israel’s next government, but recommendations for the mandate do not yet add up to a governing coalition.

05 · Security · Poland

Gunman Kills Six in Kraków

Police shot and detained the attacker after gunfire in the Main Market Square. More than a dozen people were wounded, including two officers.